AI Is Transforming Interviews and Why Most Companies Aren’t Ready Yet

As artificial intelligence becomes entrenched in the workplace, a seismic shift is occurring, not just in how we work, but in how we hire. AI-assisted interviews are rapidly emerging as a new frontier in talent acquisition, offering a glimpse into how companies are adapting (or struggling to adapt) to the demands of an AI-driven era.

AI Interview Adoption Is Growing. But Unevenly

According to BCG’s 2025 AI at Work report, AI adoption across global workforces has grown impressively. 72% of workers now use AI regularly. But dig deeper, and a revealing gap emerges. While managers and leaders have embraced AI tools at high rates (85–88%), frontline employees have stalled at just 51%. This disparity matters, especially in hiring processes, because frontline and early-career candidates are often the first to encounter automated screening or AI-facilitated interviews.

Yet even as adoption grows, AI interview deployment is not yet mainstream. Just 13% of respondents report AI agents being fully integrated into workflows, interviews included. Most companies are still experimenting, indicating that the majority of hiring teams are in the early stages of understanding how to leverage AI for interviews effectively.

What Makes AI Interviews So Transformational?

AI interviews are not just digitized versions of traditional hiring; they represent a shift.

They bring several potential benefits:

• Consistency and fairness: AI can ask standardized questions and evaluate responses without bias, critically, if trained correctly.
• Efficiency: Recruiters save hours in initial screening.
• Scalability: AI interviews can process thousands of candidates simultaneously.

But these benefits come with caveats. The BCG report highlights persistent concerns among employees: lack of oversight (46%), unclear accountability (35%), and risks of bias (32%). For AI interviews to succeed, these concerns must be addressed.

Training Is the Weakest Link

Perhaps the most revealing insight from the BCG study is the training gap. Only 36% of employees feel adequately trained in AI skills. Among frontline workers, the most likely group to be affected by AI-led screening or assessments, the number is even lower.

Training isn’t just a checkbox. BCG data shows that employees who receive at least five hours of in-depth, in-person training with coaching are dramatically more confident in using AI and see better results in their work.

For hiring managers and recruiters looking to implement AI interview platforms, this is a wake-up call: tools are only as effective as the humans who deploy and interpret them.

Shadow AI: A Growing Risk in Hiring

One striking trend is the rise of “shadow AI,” unauthorized use of AI tools by employees. Over 54% of workers say they would use unapproved AI tools if company options fall short. This could easily extend to hiring teams using unvetted AI software for candidate evaluations.

The implications are serious. Without proper oversight, AI interviews could become a source of legal and reputational risk due to algorithmic bias or improper data handling.

AI Interviews in the Global South vs. Global North

Interestingly, countries in the Global South (like India, Brazil, and South Africa) are leading in AI usage, with India topping the list at 92% regular AI use. These regions also show higher optimism toward AI, suggesting a greater openness to integrating tools like AI interviews across hiring functions.

In contrast, more conservative adoption in the Global North, especially in countries like Japan and the US, reflects caution, driven in part by job loss fears and lack of clarity about AI’s role. Keep a note of legal and compliance differences as well.

From Tools to Transformation: Rethinking the Hiring Workflow

The most forward-thinking companies aren’t just experimenting with AI interviews; they’re redesigning entire hiring workflows around AI. BCG identifies this as the next strategic frontier: moving from “tool deployment” to workflow redesign.

Organizations that invest in reshaping their processes, rather than merely adding tools, see markedly better outcomes:

• 59% report improved leadership support.
• 67% believe AI helps in better decision-making.
• 76% save over an hour daily through AI use.

In the context of interviews, this could mean integrating AI not just in the first round, but throughout: from resume screening to cultural fit assessments to onboarding.

Strategic Takeaways for Leaders

To implement AI interviews effectively, companies must focus on three foundational elements:

1. Invest in Training and Coaching

Ensure hiring teams understand not just how to use AI tools, but also when and why. In-person training and access to AI coaches make a significant difference in adoption and quality.

2. Redesign the Interview Workflow

Don’t bolt AI onto an outdated process. Instead, reimagine how candidates are assessed, how decisions are made, and where humans add value.

3. Establish Clear Governance

Combat shadow AI by offering approved tools with clear usage guidelines. Create frameworks for accountability, fairness, and explainability in AI-led hiring.

The Bottom Line

AI interviews are here, but, readiness is lagging. While the potential to enhance hiring is real, only companies that invest in people, processes, and thoughtful experimentation will capture the full value.

As AI becomes embedded in the way we work, leaders must recognize that hiring is not exempt. In fact, it might be the most visible, and vulnerable, application of AI in the changing workplace.

‍